[ LOGIN | FORUMS HOME ]
play.net: Home · Mobile Mode · Go Play!
Mark as Read
Post Post
The Chair (questions) on 05/19/2015 01:01 AM CDT
Links-arrows 1
Reply Reply

Dunder hefansteorras wid cepanne,
Dunder sunne paere lyftte wid beseon,
Wid pu bide to ba yfluo.

Awa wid cepanne,
Awa wid beseon,
Pau depas hiet sie na pas weallems


Okay, so I wanted to ask some rather basic questions here....

A) Is this a cipher of some sort? Or is it a matter of tying it into another language completely? I know for a fact it isn't a roman cipher (worked out all 52 possibilities by hand) but if it isn't the English we speak I could spend 1000+ hours on it and it wouldn't matter, which I'd prefer to avoid if that is possible.

B) If it IS a cipher does it tie to 100% modern english, no slang, broken speech, or anything that isn't in common use? Nouns being the exception of course.

Those two things I really do need to know to make any progress.

C) Are the spaces spaces? It flows like it is, but that could be misleading.

D) It's been stated this 'is' solvable but with a sample size this small anything more complex then a substitution cipher becomes awfully hard (neigh impossible). Its not an instance of multiplicative inverses under mod 26 (as 26 isn't prime and as such it doesn't form a group under multiplication (bonus points to anyone who gets what I mean by that)) or mod 27 (1^(-1) would be a or o depending on if space was 1 or a was, neither of which work). Is it something that (or more) complex? I know a small bit about crypto, mostly through number theory, but I know enough that what seems obvious to a creator can be hugely difficult for those on the outside simply because of the sheer number of ways it can be approached. The wall outside the CIA is a prime example. For instances here a 2 letter keyword cant be ruled out by the structure, but I would have to spend 100 hours trying all 650 possibilities.

and lastly E) Its been years, is it too soon to ask for a hint of some sort?

Tals player.
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/19/2015 02:15 AM CDT
Links-arrows 2
Reply Reply
My own efforts to translate it determined that it is based on some kind of archaic Germanic language.

Here were my notes from looking stuff up in piles of online dictionaries, which suggests this:

wid -> we two (dual form) -- literally wit

yfluo -> yellow?

ciepan (Old English) -> trade in, buy, sell

bide -> pray?

weall (Old English): Wall

sunne Weak Feminine Noun
1. the sun 1a. epithets or metaphors applied to the sun 1b. forms used of the sun’s course þonne sunne on setle síe then the sun may be set 2. used in phrases expressing exposure to the sun’s heat or light e.g. in or out of the sun hé sæt út on sunnan he sat out in the sun 2a. in the phrase under ~an in this world compare sublunary híe geséon under sunnan they may provide in this world 3. used metaphorically

Old English wid Modern English odd

Old English beseon Modern English look absolute physical

Old English beseón Modern English strain upon sprinkle

lyftte: Swedish: raised

paere: utterly, completely (as adverb

beseon; (Old English) look, look up

Middle English: wallen:

Dunder: thunder? Dutch

I assume you are well aware that this is vaguely covered in Casler saga, and that there is a connection between this yellow-eyed creature, and something to do with the Reivers. I'm forgetting at the moment, bu anyway I think you know all that.

My main lamentation is that Casler has written that there is similar writing on top of the Stone Eye near an astrolab or a telescope or something, but I could never get there or find this in game. Another set of words might help a little here.



Check out who's dying any time! https://twitter.com/GSIVDeathLog

>Daid: Pretty sure you have a whole big bucket as your penny jar. You never have only two cents. :p
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/19/2015 02:18 AM CDT
Links-arrows 3
Reply Reply
PS: This is one of those cases where I explicitly lament that the GS gamefeed is ASCII and not UTF-8. I have a very strong suspicion that some of these characters are meant to be other characters (with accents, or deprecated letters, or who knows). That certainly complicates life, whether it is true or because I suspect it, take your pick.



Check out who's dying any time! https://twitter.com/GSIVDeathLog

>Daid: Pretty sure you have a whole big bucket as your penny jar. You never have only two cents. :p
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/19/2015 02:57 AM CDT
Links-arrows 4
Reply Reply
<<<PS: This is one of those cases where I explicitly lament that the GS gamefeed is ASCII and not UTF-8. I have a very strong suspicion that some of these characters are meant to be other characters (with accents, or deprecated letters, or who knows). That certainly complicates life, whether it is true or because I suspect it, take your pick.>>>

It certainly looks a lot like Old English. Could be that some P's are actually thorn symbols.

I looked up some of the words in OE, maybe these will help--

cepan = to observe, to await
beseon = to look

aefensteorra = the evening star

sunne = sun
lyft = sky

awa = always
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/19/2015 03:21 AM CDT
Links-arrows 6
Reply Reply
A couple other possibilities:

pas = pæþ meaning path (ae ligature, thorn)
weallems maybe some connection to weallen, to spring forth/flow?




Fyonn's player
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/19/2015 03:28 AM CDT
Links-arrows 7
Reply Reply
I'm mostly trying to approach it as a substitution cipher of some kind because that's a side of things I have some strength with, on top of that anyone can sit down with a pen and paper and work through ciphers. If it is Old English.... linguistics is a field I have nothing to contribute and I actually feel it would be somewhat against the spirit of things if 'it can be solved' required a masters degree in that field.

Are you down in RR at the moment? I should of copied the text from sitting in the chair as well as the room while I was down there, but didn't cause I didn't expect this to turn into something tugging at me for this long.

Also, who is that quote from?

Tal.
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/19/2015 04:06 AM CDT
Links-arrows 8
Reply Reply
<pas = pæþ meaning path (ae ligature, thorn)
weallems maybe some connection to weallen, to spring forth/flow?>

I feel like a reference to "weall" (wall) makes more sense in context, especially if "na pas" mean something like "not pass". This is what I have so far on a guess:

Dunder hefansteorras wid cepanne,
? evening-star we await

Dunder sunne paere lyftte wid beseon,
? sun ? sky we watch

Wid pu bide to ba yfluo.
we ? pray ? ? evil

Awa wid cepanne,
always we await

Awa wid beseon,
always we watch

Pau depas hiet sie na pas weallems
? deep-water ? ? not pass wall
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/19/2015 08:32 AM CDT
Links-arrows 9
Reply Reply
You folks are getting very close.

Since you're so close and it's been about seven years since it was released here's some major hintage:

1) I knew that Gemstone players had a higher likelihood than your average Joe of recognizing a language no longer in use.

2) I totally used an online dictionary and the grammar is probably more in line with modern english.

3) Just to avoid it being a simple cut and paste translation, I might have tweaked words here and there, adding a letter, subtracting a letter, so if a word doesn't translate perfectly, it might require looking at the word and asking yourself, for example, "Does it make more sense if I remove one of these letters?"

4)This translation is accurate:

"Awa wid cepanne,
always we await

Awa wid beseon,
always we watch

5) Concerning this translation (see (3) and it's very close to being completely translated:

Dunder hefansteorras wid cepanne,
? evening-star we await

Dunder sunne paere lyftte wid beseon,
? sun ? sky we watch


Yeah, I know this process, almost entirely void of logical code breaking was mean. I TOTALLY KNOW IT. :D

GM Scribes
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/19/2015 08:37 AM CDT
Links-arrows 10
Reply Reply
P.S.

As mentioned above, Casler did write about discovering the same language on the Stone Eye (but in an area not currently accessible to players - okay, it exists only in the written word) and his history of the town mentions the people who built the winged chair. Lastly, also correctly, the Reiver document also connects to those same events (albeit, briefly).

GM Scribes
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/19/2015 10:26 AM CDT
Links-arrows 11
Reply Reply
>Dunder sunne paere lyftte wid beseon,
>? sun ? sky we watch

Here was the only sentence I also made any headway with.

Attempt A was missing a word and a word-for-word attempt: (Thunder?) sun complete raised with looking
Attempt B was trying to make a more grammatical statement in English: Looking on the complete sun rise




Check out who's dying any time! https://twitter.com/GSIVDeathLog

>Daid: Pretty sure you have a whole big bucket as your penny jar. You never have only two cents. :p
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/19/2015 09:04 PM CDT
Links-arrows 12
Reply Reply

frolkrm hirildat muslubri corum

Clunk

(Buy your swords at CBD weapons in Zul Logoth.)
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/19/2015 09:07 PM CDT
Links-arrows 13
Reply Reply

and ... is hter not writing in an area of the graveyard that remains untranslated? on a slab or something?

Clunk

(Buy your swords at CBD weapons in Zul Logoth.)
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/19/2015 11:24 PM CDT
Links-arrows 14
Reply Reply
Some other possible matches, switching p/thorn and dropping or swapping some letters:

dunder < under 'under'
paere < þǽr 'therein'
pu < þu 'you'
to < tó 'so as to'
ba < ban 'command, interdict'
pau < þá 'when, then'
depas < deáþ 'death'
hiet < hit 'it'
sie < sié 'to be'
na < ná 'not'
pas < þás 'this'

The last line still needs a conclusion to tie it together. We've had suggestions for the final word ('wall', 'wellspring'), and there's other options in wælhlem 'onslaught' or in general words derived from wæl- 'the dead', but knowing who wrote the inscription may help.
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/19/2015 11:59 PM CDT
Links-arrows 15
Reply Reply
<<and ... is hter not writing in an area of the graveyard that remains untranslated? on a slab or something?>> - CLUNK

It was something like.. "Dha baes'irin ta geilach i shiath ta sidar ~ Oraesh'lan'dha ta geilach ~ Oraesh'lan da Gosaena"... I know that isn't quite right, but it was fifteen years ago, and there are Grimswarm all over the place right now.

The same language was used by the archmages when they made the world stop spinning in the Vishmiir storyline, so I assume there was a glossary somewhere that as far as I know we never saw. I hacked away at it with no luck at the time because there was seemingly no way to crack it.

- Xorus' player



>A monastic lich points a skeletal finger at you and exclaims, "Your soul is forfeit!"
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/20/2015 01:36 AM CDT
Links-arrows 16
Reply Reply
Making an attempt...


Beneath the evening star, we wait

Beneath the 'noon' sun, we watch --- (translating noon sun from a sun high in the sky)

While you remain with the evil ones



Always we wait

Always we watch

The deep sea cannot hide the wanderers from our sight (???)



For the last line, Pau depas hiet sie na pas weallems, working with:
þæs déopes - The deep sea
hilest – hides
síen - power of seeing /power of sight/ sight /vision
Old English ne Modern English not
pa= the/that/those
weallian - to go abroad travel wander go as pilgrim
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/20/2015 09:43 AM CDT
Links-arrows 17
Reply Reply
I reiterate y'all are getting pretty close!



GM Scribes
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/20/2015 07:20 PM CDT
Links-arrows 18
Reply Reply
Just curious as I have zero connection to the Casler storyline-- is this language, IC, supposed to be the elder Kannalar tongue mentioned in the Turamzzyrian timeline documentation? I've often pondered how much this old (mostly lost, I'm guessing) language would be remembered and used in today's Empire.

/seo, wheels and skulls department/
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/21/2015 08:56 AM CDT
Links-arrows 19
Reply Reply
Excellent question!

When I was human and Rest guru, I did envisioned this language as being the older Kannalan dialect and used it appropriately to identify objects or places or events to that time period. There are parts of the Empire today that were never 100% culturally conquered by the Turamzzyrian Empire, so to speak, but were absorbed with much of their Kannalan era identity still intact. That identity has definitely decayed since being absorbed, but there could definitely be scholars who recognize the language and would probably be a much better translator than Casler (educated, but not THAT educated).

Of note, Casler wrote about discovering the same language as on the chair also on the Stone Eye, but it wasn't related to the events of the Casler Huntington Saga.

In a Giantman doc I'm working on, I do plan to provide more info about the Kannalan Empire. :D

GM Scribes
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/21/2015 01:57 PM CDT
Links-arrows 20
Reply Reply
Another attempt oh diabolical one!!!


Always we wait

Always we watch

While the deep sea hides the wanderers from our sight




For the last line, Pau depas hiet sie na pas weallems, working with:
þa/ þá /þý - while/when
déopes - deep sea
hilest – hides
síen - power of seeing /power of sight/ sight /vision
Old English ne Modern English not
pa= the/that/those
weallian - to go abroad travel wander go as pilgrim
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/21/2015 03:30 PM CDT
Links-arrows 21
Reply Reply
The sentences should be grammatically correct, not in the sense of having OE declensions but when we translate them they should all have clear subject/verb phrases. They would also have to make sense as a part of the history of Marsh Keep, which I'm not familiar with but might have something to do with necromancy.

3. Wid pu bide to ba yfluo
We to-you pray to banish evil

ba -- OE bannan, 'to summon/command, to prohibit/curse'
The fact that it could mean either 'summon' or 'banish' may be an intentional ambiguity, but I think it is the latter since the prior invocations of the evening star and the sun are of typically positive symbols.

6. Pau depas hiet sie na pas weallems

Pau -- þá 'when', and I think it is specifically in the sense of '(we wait) for the time when...' so that it forms a parallel with the first three lines, describing an event which has not yet come to pass.
depas -- could be from deóp 'the deep', or if using a thorn instead of p, deáþ 'death'. The latter seems slightly more likely in context but I'm not too sure.
hiet -- I'm inclined to think this is a simple third-person pronoun instead of something more substantial.
sie -- sie is the OE subjunctive form of 'to be' which would match the mood of the clause. If so, then it is the main verb of the clause.
na -- 'not'.
pas -- þás 'this'

So perhaps, "for when death it is not this [weallems]", where the final word is a noun.
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/22/2015 12:08 AM CDT
Links-arrows 22
Reply Reply
>So perhaps, "for when death it is not this [weallems]", where the final word is a noun.

cwealm - death murder slaughter torment pain plague pestilence ((the/that þæs) cwealmes)

>Pau depas hiet sie na pas weallems

That death will not be this torment


So... working with what has been suggested, and refined, I submit the following:


Under the evening star, we wait
Under the shining sun, we watch
We to-you pray to banish evil

Always we wait
Always we watch
That death will not be this torment



All I can say is that this more closely fits the visions. So let's keep translating!
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/22/2015 02:12 AM CDT
Links-arrows 23
Reply Reply
Even if its not right, I like that one a lot.

Also... ducked out, because linguistics isn't my thing, but I am following this closely to see what is come up with.

Also, also.... Kayse, I owe you 72k.

Also, also, also... meh, that one can wait.

Taluric.
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/22/2015 09:13 AM CDT
Links-arrows 24
Reply Reply
Lines 3 and 6 just need some tweaking.

You two are narrowing down all possibilities!

GM Scribes
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/24/2015 03:50 PM CDT
Links-arrows 25
Reply Reply
>>Also, also.... Kayse, I owe you 72k.<<

O, RLY? Hmmm. Did we bet on something?! ;)

~Kayse



(OOC) You quietly whisper to Riend, "What's the verb for glancing at someone and exhaling?"
(OOC) Farain's player whispers, "I think its kiss farain."
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/24/2015 08:13 PM CDT
Links-arrows 26
Reply Reply
When I emptied my pack back into your bag after singing it appears I hit an item limit for that verb and managed to have 2 bloodjewels and a bunch of sapphires not go over.

I didn't know that was a thing.

Value when I sold them in Mule was 72k, so... yeah... that's what I owe you.

Tal.
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/26/2015 09:42 AM CDT
Links-arrows 27
Reply Reply
Kayse needs to come live in Icemule so she can pick our boxes!
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/26/2015 09:53 AM CDT
Links-arrows 28
Reply Reply
Or atleast prevent me from blowing myself up from playing box roulette with my wedges. :)

I'd rather die instead of paying that thief in Icemule.
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/26/2015 10:36 AM CDT
Links-arrows 29
Reply Reply

Oh and a complete guess I'll throw out there With no thought behind it from just looking at what's out there now.

We shall pray to banish evil
We will fight to banish evil
We will unite to banish evil (or vanquish)

That death will not be this journey
That death will not be our end


Complete guesses...
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/26/2015 11:21 AM CDT
Links-arrows 30
Reply Reply
>>Kayse needs to come live in Icemule so she can pick our boxes!<<

Boo! Icemule! NEVER!

~Kayse

P.S-Can't you pick your own boxes?
P.P.S-I need more acid vials. :) <3



(OOC) You quietly whisper to Riend, "What's the verb for glancing at someone and exhaling?"
(OOC) Farain's player whispers, "I think its kiss farain."
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/26/2015 12:21 PM CDT
Links-arrows 31
Reply Reply
<<Oh and a complete guess I'll throw out there With no thought behind it from just looking at what's out there now.

We shall pray to banish evil
We will fight to banish evil
We will unite to banish evil (or vanquish)

That death will not be this journey
That death will not be our end>>

Not sure if you got it, but I like that.
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/26/2015 12:32 PM CDT
Links-arrows 32
Reply Reply
If you come to Icemule I'll let you pick all the boxes and you can have all my acid viles :)
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/26/2015 12:33 PM CDT
Links-arrows 33
Reply Reply
>>Value when I sold them in Mule was 72k, so... yeah... that's what I owe you.<<

Eh, not too worried about it. Whenever our paths cross again, or heck keep it for a tip :P

~Kayse



(OOC) You quietly whisper to Riend, "What's the verb for glancing at someone and exhaling?"
(OOC) Farain's player whispers, "I think its kiss farain."
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/26/2015 12:36 PM CDT
Links-arrows 34
Reply Reply
I'll even let you pick my boxes!
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/26/2015 12:56 PM CDT
Links-arrows 35
Reply Reply
That death will not be our weakness?
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/26/2015 05:46 PM CDT
Links-arrows 36
Reply Reply
Someone dropped all his picking skills and is now learning what it's like to live like the rest of us. Poor thing....
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/26/2015 05:59 PM CDT
Links-arrows 37
Reply Reply
Hey now! I can still "open" my boxes! Nothing wrong with a little wedge roulette.
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/27/2015 09:59 AM CDT
Links-arrows 38
Reply Reply
>>Someone dropped all his picking skills and is now learning what it's like to live like the rest of us. Poor thing....<<

Awww, if you want boxes opened, come to River's Rest. :) Can't even do ANYTHING the last two nights but open boxes for people.

RLEN WHERE THE HECK ARE YOU?


~Kayse



(OOC) You quietly whisper to Riend, "What's the verb for glancing at someone and exhaling?"
(OOC) Farain's player whispers, "I think its kiss farain."
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/27/2015 01:23 PM CDT
Links-arrows 39
Reply Reply
He's on my shoulder!

Another crack at it:


We shall pray to vanquish evil

That death will not be our anguish.

Not really too much different than what was already provided from others.
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/28/2015 12:03 AM CDT
Links-arrows 40
Reply Reply


Feel like we're just chasing around in circles now.

How's this tweak?


Under the evening star, we wait
Under the shining sun, we watch
While you remain to banish evil

Always we wait
Always we watch
May our death not be this torment

where "ba" in line 3 is a form of béodan = to command decree summon banish
Reply Reply
Re: The Chair (questions) on 05/28/2015 03:34 PM CDT
Links-arrows 41
Reply Reply
I haven't had a chance to respond the last week or so, but I'll provide an update tomorrow or what not!

GM Scribes
Reply Reply
Post Post
Mark as Read